There’s something undeniably comforting about the classics—and when it comes to timeless Southern recipes, pimento cheese is right at the top of the list. Creamy, tangy, rich, and just a little bit peppery, this old-fashioned favorite has been gracing tables for generations. Whether it’s spread between slices of soft white bread, served alongside crackers and fresh veggies, or dolloped onto a juicy burger, pimento cheese has a way of turning even the simplest snack into something special.
In this post, I’m sharing a no-fuss, tried-and-true recipe for making old-fashioned pimento cheese at home. It’s quick to prepare, calls for just a handful of simple ingredients, and delivers that nostalgic flavor we all know and love. If you’ve only ever tried the store-bought version, get ready for a game changer—because nothing compares to homemade.
Whether you’re hosting a casual get-together, packing lunchboxes, or just craving a cozy snack, this recipe is the perfect go-to. And the best part? You can customize it to your taste—make it smooth or chunky, mild or spicy, and enjoy it your way.
So, grab your mixing bowl and let’s whip up a batch of this Southern staple that’s as simple as it is delicious. Trust me, once you try this homemade pimento cheese, you’ll never go back to the store-bought stuff again.
What Is Old-Fashioned Pimento Cheese?
A Southern Classic with a Rich History
Pimento cheese is more than just a spread—it’s a beloved tradition, especially in the American South. Its exact origins are debated, but it rose to fame in the early 20th century when pimentos (mild, sweet red peppers) were first imported from Spain and combined with creamy cheese spreads. What started as a novelty quickly became a staple in Southern kitchens, loved for its bold flavor, creamy texture, and versatility. Often nicknamed “the pâté of the South,” pimento cheese has become an iconic comfort food served at everything from picnics to parties to family dinners.
Key Ingredients That Make It Special
At its heart, old-fashioned pimento cheese is a simple combination of shredded cheddar cheese, diced pimentos, and mayonnaise. But don’t let its simplicity fool you—when blended just right, these ingredients create a rich, tangy, and slightly spicy spread that’s incredibly satisfying. Some variations might include cream cheese for extra richness, or a dash of garlic powder, onion, or cayenne pepper for added flavor. The key is balance: you want a creamy texture with just enough zing to make your taste buds dance.
Common Ways to Enjoy Pimento Cheese
One of the reasons pimento cheese has stayed popular for so long is its versatility. You’ll find it spread between slices of soft white bread for a classic sandwich, dolloped on crackers as a quick snack, or even melted on top of burgers or baked potatoes. In the South, it’s often served at potlucks, tailgates, and holiday gatherings—comforting, crowd-pleasing, and easy to make in big batches. Whether served cold or warm, chunky or smooth, it’s the kind of recipe that feels like home.
Why Make Pimento Cheese at Home?
Freshness and Flavor You Can Taste
When you make pimento cheese at home, the difference in flavor is immediate. Store-bought versions often contain preservatives and stabilizers that can dull the taste or affect the texture. Homemade, on the other hand, gives you that fresh, bold flavor you just can’t replicate in a factory. From the sharpness of the cheddar to the subtle sweetness of the pimentos, every bite is vibrant and satisfying. Plus, you get full control over the ingredients—no mystery additives or overly processed fillers here.
Customizable to Your Preferences
One of the best things about making pimento cheese from scratch is that it’s endlessly customizable. Prefer it smooth and creamy? Use a food processor. Want more texture? Hand-mix it with a fork or spoon. Love spice? Add a dash of cayenne or chopped jalapeños. You can also play with different cheeses, like pepper jack or smoked gouda, or mix in extras like chopped pickles, caramelized onions, or fresh herbs. Making it at home means you can tweak the flavor and texture exactly to your taste.
Better Than Store-Bought
Let’s be honest—homemade pimento cheese just tastes better. The richness of freshly shredded cheese combined with quality mayonnaise and real pimentos creates a depth of flavor that the packaged stuff simply can’t match. It’s creamier, fresher, and more flavorful, plus you avoid that overly processed or too-salty aftertaste that some commercial brands have. Once you try it homemade, you’ll wonder how you ever settled for anything less.
Budget-Friendly and Easy
Homemade pimento cheese is also easy on the wallet. With just a few inexpensive ingredients—most of which you probably already have in your kitchen—you can whip up a big batch in no time. It’s quick to prepare, stores well, and can be used in so many different ways throughout the week. From work lunches to impromptu snacks to weekend brunch boards, it’s a low-effort, high-reward recipe that fits into just about any lifestyle.
Simple Ingredients You’ll Need
One of the things that makes old-fashioned pimento cheese so appealing is how simple the ingredient list is. You don’t need anything fancy—just a few kitchen staples come together to make something truly delicious.
Cheddar Cheese: The Star of the Show
Sharp cheddar cheese is the traditional base for pimento cheese, and it’s what gives the spread its rich, savory flavor. For the best texture and taste, it’s highly recommended to grate the cheese yourself rather than using pre-shredded, which often contains anti-caking agents that can affect creaminess. You can also mix in some mild cheddar for balance, or even experiment with white cheddar, smoked gouda, or Monterey Jack if you’re feeling creative.
Pimentos: What They Are and Why They Matter
Pimentos are small, sweet red peppers that bring a mild tang and a pop of color to the spread. You’ll typically find them in jars, already diced and ready to use. Their mellow flavor complements the sharpness of the cheese beautifully. If you can’t find pimentos, finely chopped roasted red peppers are a great substitute and offer a similar taste and texture.
Mayonnaise: The Creamy Base
A good-quality mayonnaise ties everything together, giving pimento cheese its signature creamy consistency. Southern recipes often favor Duke’s Mayonnaise for its rich flavor and slight tang, but any full-fat mayo you like will work well. You can also mix in a bit of cream cheese for a thicker, more indulgent version.
Optional Add-Ins for Extra Flavor
This is where you can really make the recipe your own:
- Garlic powder or onion powder for savory depth
- Cayenne pepper or hot sauce for a spicy kick
- Diced jalapeños for some heat and crunch
- Paprika or smoked paprika for warmth and color
- Worcestershire sauce or mustard for a slight umami punch
Pimento cheese is incredibly forgiving and open to interpretation—just taste as you go and find your perfect balance of creaminess, tang, and spice.
How to Make Old-Fashioned Pimento Cheese
Making homemade pimento cheese is quick, easy, and super satisfying. It takes less than 15 minutes to prepare, and once you try it, you’ll never go back to store-bought again. Here’s how to do it:
Step-by-Step Instructions
Ingredients:
- 2 cups sharp cheddar cheese, freshly grated
- ½ cup mayonnaise (adjust to desired creaminess)
- 4 oz jar of diced pimentos, drained
- Salt and black pepper to taste
- Optional: 2–3 oz cream cheese (softened), garlic powder, cayenne, or a splash of hot sauce
Instructions:
- Grate the cheese.
For best results, use freshly grated sharp cheddar cheese. It blends more smoothly and tastes richer than pre-shredded cheese. - Drain the pimentos.
Make sure the diced pimentos are well-drained to avoid a watery spread. You can pat them dry with a paper towel if needed. - Combine the base.
In a mixing bowl, combine the grated cheese, pimentos, and mayonnaise. If using cream cheese, add it now. - Mix until blended.
Use a spoon or spatula to stir the mixture until creamy and fully combined. For a smoother spread, you can use a hand mixer or food processor. For a chunkier, more rustic texture, mix it by hand. - Season to taste.
Add salt, pepper, and any optional spices you like—such as garlic powder, onion powder, cayenne, or a few dashes of hot sauce. Taste and adjust as needed. - Chill (optional but recommended).
Letting it chill in the fridge for 30 minutes to an hour helps the flavors meld together beautifully, but you can serve it immediately if you’re short on time.
Texture Tips: Smooth vs. Chunky
- Smooth: Use a food processor or hand mixer to get a whipped, creamy consistency. This is great for spreading on sandwiches.
- Chunky: Mix by hand and leave larger cheese shreds and pimento pieces intact. Perfect for scooping with crackers or veggies.
Storage Tips and Shelf Life
Homemade pimento cheese stores well in the fridge. Keep it in an airtight container for up to one week. Always use a clean spoon when serving to maintain freshness. Avoid freezing—it can alter the texture and make the spread watery after thawing.
Make-Ahead Options for Entertaining
Planning a party or picnic? Pimento cheese is a perfect make-ahead dish. Prepare it a day in advance to let the flavors deepen, and serve it straight from the fridge or at room temperature. It pairs beautifully with a charcuterie board, sandwich platter, or veggie tray.
Creative Ways to Serve Pimento Cheese
Pimento cheese isn’t just for spreading on bread—its creamy, tangy goodness is incredibly versatile. Whether you’re looking for a simple snack, a crowd-pleasing appetizer, or something a little more unique, here are some creative ways to enjoy homemade pimento cheese:
As a Sandwich Spread (Classic or Grilled)
Pimento cheese makes a fantastic sandwich spread, but why stop at the classic? For a simple lunch or snack, spread it between slices of white or whole wheat bread. If you’re feeling indulgent, try a grilled pimento cheese sandwich—just like a grilled cheese, but with an extra layer of flavor from the pimentos. The cheese melts beautifully, and the crispy, golden bread creates the perfect contrast. You can also experiment with other breads like sourdough, rye, or even croissants for a gourmet touch.
As a Dip with Crackers or Veggies
For a quick and easy appetizer, serve your pimento cheese as a dip. Arrange a platter of assorted crackers, fresh vegetable sticks (think celery, carrots, and bell peppers), or even pita chips for a healthy option. Pimento cheese also pairs beautifully with pickles or olives for a tangy contrast. You can add a drizzle of hot sauce or sprinkle fresh herbs on top to elevate the presentation.
As a Topping for Burgers or Baked Potatoes
Take your classic burger or baked potato to the next level by adding a dollop of pimento cheese on top. The richness of the spread complements the savory flavors of the meat or potato, and the tangy bite of the pimentos offers a nice balance. Pimento cheese burgers are particularly popular in the South, and they pair perfectly with crispy fries or a side salad.
In Recipes: Stuffed Celery, Deviled Eggs, or Pasta
Pimento cheese is a surprisingly versatile ingredient in other recipes. Try stuffing celery sticks with pimento cheese for a crunchy, savory snack. You can also spoon it into deviled eggs for a unique twist on the classic appetizer. For a fun pasta dish, toss pimento cheese into warm macaroni or pasta salads, creating a creamy, Southern-inspired flavor that’s sure to impress at barbecues or family gatherings.
As Part of a Charcuterie or Appetizer Board
Pimento cheese is a perfect addition to a charcuterie board. Pair it with a variety of cheeses, smoked meats, olives, nuts, and fruit. The smooth, tangy spread adds a burst of flavor that complements the richness of cheeses like brie, gouda, and aged cheddar. Serve with crusty bread or crackers to complete the spread.
In Stuffed Chicken or Wraps
For a twist on classic stuffed chicken, spread pimento cheese inside chicken breasts before baking. The cheese melts inside, creating a gooey, flavorful filling that pairs wonderfully with roasted vegetables or a fresh salad. Alternatively, try using pimento cheese as a filling for wraps, alongside grilled chicken or fresh greens, for a hearty and satisfying meal.
Pimento cheese is one of those recipes that adapts to nearly every meal or snack occasion. With its balance of creaminess, sharpness, and mild spice, you’ll find endless ways to enjoy it. Get creative, and you might discover your new favorite way to serve this Southern classic!
Table of Contents
Pimento Cheese Recipe – Cookie and Kate
Iced Americano Recipe Refreshing and Bold Coffee Drink for Hot Days – labelrecipes.com