Looking for a shot that’s as fun to make as it is to drink? The Buttery Nipple is a sweet, smooth, and slightly cheeky classic that never goes out of style. Whether you’re planning a party, hosting friends, or just want to treat yourself to something a little indulgent, this buttery and boozy delight is sure to impress. In this post, I’ll share the best Buttery Nipple recipe you’ll ever try—easy to whip up, irresistibly creamy, and guaranteed to be a crowd-pleaser.
What Is a Buttery Nipple Shot?
Origins and Name
The Buttery Nipple shot first gained popularity in the 1980s, a time known for its love of sweet, layered cocktails. Like many cheekily named drinks of the era, its suggestive title helped it become a conversation starter and a party favorite. Despite its playful name, the Buttery Nipple is all about smooth flavors and a velvety finish—far more sophisticated than its title might suggest.
Cocktail Culture Favorite
This shot has stood the test of time thanks to its simplicity and rich flavor. You’ll still see it on bar menus around the world, especially in party settings or at casual gatherings. It’s often one of the first shots people try when getting into cocktails because it’s easy to make, not overly strong in taste, and generally well-liked by both novice and experienced drinkers. Plus, its layered appearance adds a touch of flair.
Flavor Profile
The Buttery Nipple is sweet, creamy, and indulgent—think dessert in a shot glass. The butterscotch schnapps brings a warm, candy-like flavor, while the Irish cream adds richness and a smooth finish. Together, they create a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth experience that’s hard to resist. Despite being sweet, it packs a gentle punch thanks to the liqueurs’ alcohol content.
Ingredients You’ll Need
Butterscotch Schnapps
The foundation of a Buttery Nipple shot, Butterscotch Schnapps brings that signature sweet, buttery flavor. It’s a liqueur that combines the smoothness of schnapps with the rich, sugary taste of butterscotch, making it the perfect base for this drink. Popular brands like DeKuyper and Goldschlager offer variations, but look for a high-quality one to ensure your shot is as smooth and flavorful as possible. The sweetness of butterscotch is what gives the shot its indulgent flavor, so don’t skimp on this ingredient!
Irish Cream (like Baileys)
The second key ingredient is Irish Cream, which gives the Buttery Nipple its signature creamy texture. Baileys Irish Cream is the most well-known brand, but there are several alternatives, including Carolans and The Irishman, which also work wonderfully. Irish Cream is a blend of Irish whiskey, cream, and other flavorings, making it the perfect complement to the butterscotch schnapps. The richness of Irish Cream creates the smooth, velvety top layer, making the shot both creamy and flavorful. It’s also the ingredient that gives the shot that buttery smooth finish.
Optional Add-ins
While the classic recipe only requires the two main ingredients (butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream), you can get creative with some optional add-ins:
- Whipped Cream: For a richer texture and a bit of flair, a dollop of whipped cream on top can make the shot even more indulgent.
- Splash of Vodka: If you want to give the shot a bit more strength without losing its creamy sweetness, a splash of vodka can increase the alcohol content while maintaining its smoothness.
- Chocolate Syrup: A drizzle of chocolate syrup around the inside of the glass can add a decadent twist to the flavor profile, making it even more dessert-like.
These add-ins aren’t essential, but they can add a fun, personalized touch to the shot, depending on your taste preferences.
Tips on Choosing Quality Liqueurs
When making a Buttery Nipple shot, the quality of your ingredients makes a big difference in the overall flavor. Butterscotch Schnapps and Irish Cream are both relatively affordable, but opting for premium brands can elevate your drink. When selecting Irish Cream, for example, look for one that uses real cream and high-quality whiskey for a smoother taste. For schnapps, a brand with rich, natural butterscotch flavor is key to ensuring your shot tastes as delicious as possible.
Best Buttery Nipple Recipe (Step-by-Step)
Butterscotch Schnapps
The foundation of a Buttery Nipple shot, Butterscotch Schnapps brings that signature sweet, buttery flavor. It’s a liqueur that combines the smoothness of schnapps with the rich, sugary taste of butterscotch, making it the perfect base for this drink. Popular brands like DeKuyper and Goldschlager offer variations, but look for a high-quality one to ensure your shot is as smooth and flavorful as possible. The sweetness of butterscotch is what gives the shot its indulgent flavor, so don’t skimp on this ingredient!
Irish Cream (like Baileys)
The second key ingredient is Irish Cream, which gives the Buttery Nipple its signature creamy texture. Baileys Irish Cream is the most well-known brand, but there are several alternatives, including Carolans and The Irishman, which also work wonderfully. Irish Cream is a blend of Irish whiskey, cream, and other flavorings, making it the perfect complement to the butterscotch schnapps. The richness of Irish Cream creates the smooth, velvety top layer, making the shot both creamy and flavorful. It’s also the ingredient that gives the shot that buttery smooth finish.
Optional Add-ins
While the classic recipe only requires the two main ingredients (butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream), you can get creative with some optional add-ins:
- Whipped Cream: For a richer texture and a bit of flair, a dollop of whipped cream on top can make the shot even more indulgent.
- Splash of Vodka: If you want to give the shot a bit more strength without losing its creamy sweetness, a splash of vodka can increase the alcohol content while maintaining its smoothness.
- Chocolate Syrup: A drizzle of chocolate syrup around the inside of the glass can add a decadent twist to the flavor profile, making it even more dessert-like.
These add-ins aren’t essential, but they can add a fun, personalized touch to the shot, depending on your taste preferences.
Tips on Choosing Quality Liqueurs
When making a Buttery Nipple shot, the quality of your ingredients makes a big difference in the overall flavor. Butterscotch Schnapps and Irish Cream are both relatively affordable, but opting for premium brands can elevate your drink. When selecting Irish Cream, for example, look for one that uses real cream and high-quality whiskey for a smoother taste. For schnapps, a brand with rich, natural butterscotch flavor is key to ensuring your shot tastes as delicious as possible.
Variations to Try
Slippery Nipple
A popular variation of the Buttery Nipple is the Slippery Nipple, which introduces Sambuca to the mix. This variation adds a slightly herbal and anise-flavored kick to the sweet, creamy base. To make a Slippery Nipple, simply layer Sambuca on top of the Buttery Nipple’s classic ingredients (butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream). The result is a unique combination of sweetness, creaminess, and a bold, licorice-like finish. It’s a fun way to give the classic shot an unexpected twist and make your drink stand out at parties.
Flaming Buttery Nipple
For a dramatic touch, try the Flaming Buttery Nipple! This variation involves lighting the shot on fire for a visually striking effect. While this variation isn’t for the faint of heart, it’s sure to impress your guests. To make a Flaming Buttery Nipple:
- Prepare the classic Buttery Nipple shot with the butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream.
- Carefully float a small amount of 151-proof rum (or any high-proof rum) on top of the drink. The higher alcohol content allows the drink to be safely lit.
- Light the shot with a match (be careful!).
- Extinguish the flame before drinking, either by blowing it out or covering it with a coaster.
This variation adds an extra layer of excitement and is perfect for a bold presentation at a party, but be sure to follow proper safety precautions when handling fire.
Buttery Nipple Martini
Turn your favorite shot into a sippable cocktail with the Buttery Nipple Martini. This variation is perfect if you’re looking to enjoy the flavors of the classic shot in a more sophisticated, full-sized format. To create this martini version:
- In a shaker, combine 1.5 oz butterscotch schnapps, 1 oz Irish cream, and 1 oz vodka.
- Add ice and shake well until chilled.
- Strain the mixture into a chilled martini glass.
- Garnish with a light drizzle of chocolate syrup or a few chocolate shavings for an extra indulgent touch.
The Buttery Nipple Martini has the same sweet, creamy taste of the original shot but in a more elegant form, perfect for sipping slowly at a dinner party or a night out.
Vegan/Dairy-Free Alternatives
For those who follow a vegan or dairy-free lifestyle, you can still enjoy a delicious Buttery Nipple! Simply swap out the traditional dairy ingredients for plant-based alternatives:
- Vegan Irish Cream: Brands like Baileys Almande offer a dairy-free version of Irish cream made with almond milk and infused with the same smooth whiskey flavors.
- Butterscotch Schnapps: Most butterscotch schnapps are already vegan-friendly, but always check the label to make sure there are no hidden dairy ingredients.
- Coconut Cream or Oat Milk: For a richer texture similar to the original Irish cream, consider using coconut cream or oat milk combined with a bit of sweetener like maple syrup.
This variation ensures that everyone can enjoy the sweet and creamy flavors of the Buttery Nipple, regardless of dietary preferences.
When and How to Serve Buttery Nipples
Perfect for Parties
The Buttery Nipple is an ideal shot for any casual get-together or party. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, throwing a housewarming, or hosting a themed event, this drink brings an element of fun and sweetness that everyone can enjoy. The shot’s vibrant, layered look also makes it visually appealing, which can make your gathering feel a little more special.
It’s easy to prepare in batches, especially when making a large number of shots for a crowd. You can pre-make the ingredients and have them ready to pour when guests are ready for a toast. It’s also a great shot for those who prefer sweeter, smoother drinks without the overpowering alcohol taste.
Girls’ Night & Game Night Favorite
The Buttery Nipple is a hit on girls’ nights and game nights. Its playful name and creamy texture make it the perfect drink to share with friends. Whether you’re playing board games, enjoying a movie marathon, or just chatting, the Buttery Nipple adds an element of fun and indulgence to the evening. Plus, it’s easy to drink without being too strong or overwhelming, making it perfect for casual sipping throughout the night.
To make it even more fun, you can create a Buttery Nipple tasting station where guests can mix their own variations, such as adding whipped cream, chocolate syrup, or trying out the Slippery Nipple variation. This turns it into an interactive and enjoyable experience.
Pairing Ideas
While the Buttery Nipple is delicious on its own, you can elevate the experience by pairing it with complementary snacks and desserts. Since the drink is rich and sweet, balance it with something savory or lightly sweet:
- Savory Pairings: Serve it alongside salty snacks like pretzels, cheese platters, or chips. The saltiness helps balance the sweetness of the drink.
- Dessert Pairings: For a dessert-focused pairing, think chocolate cake, brownies, or mini cheesecakes. These pairings work especially well for a dessert-themed evening or if you’re serving the Buttery Nipple as a dessert shot.
- Fruity Pairings: Light, fruity desserts like lemon tarts or fruit salad can offer a refreshing contrast to the drink’s richness.
Responsible Enjoyment
Although the Buttery Nipple is sweet and easy to drink, it still contains alcohol, so it’s important to enjoy it responsibly. Here are a few tips for serving it safely:
- Know Your Limits: The drink is quite sweet, and it’s easy to forget it has alcohol, so be mindful of how much you’re drinking.
- Encourage Water Breaks: Since it’s a creamy shot, it’s important to keep hydrated with water in between rounds to avoid feeling too full or sluggish.
- Serve in Moderation: While it’s tempting to make this shot the star of the night, offer a variety of drink options to ensure guests have choices and can pace themselves.
A little goes a long way with the Buttery Nipple—so serve it in smaller amounts (like in shot glasses) to keep the night fun and festive.
Table of Contents
How to Make the Perfect Orange Crush Recipe at Home – labelrecipes.com